Aristotelian Syllogisms

From docs.reasonspace.com
Revision as of 17:14, 30 August 2024 by GSalmieri (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Syllogism is the word in Aristotle's Greek that is translated "deduction." In English, the term has come to refer specifically to deductive arguments with two premises. Aristotle went through all possible combinations of two premises and a conclusion that could be made with propositions of the form “All/Some A are/aren’t B” to figure out which ones were valid deductions. He identified 14 valid forms, all of which could be restated in four forms which he called "perfect."

Later logicians identified 10 more forms, which could also be restated in terms of Aristotle's four perfect forms. All 24 forms were later given names by Medieval logicians. We can call these the Aristotelian Syllogisms.

Why, in each of these cases, do the premises necessitate the conclusion? It is because one premise is a universal proposition saying something about everything of a certain sort and the other premise tells us that something else is that sort of thing. The conclusion then applies the universal premise about all things of the sort to the thing that the other premise tells us is a member of that sort. If the universal premise is really true, and the thing in question really belongs to the relevant sort, then the universal premise will, of course, have to apply to that thing.

The Perfect (or First-Figure) Syllogisms

Barbara

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Celarent

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Darii

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Ferio

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Second Figure Syllogisms

Cesare

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Camestres

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Festino

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Baroco

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Third Figure Syllogisms

Darapti

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Felapton

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Disamis

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Datisi

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Bocardo

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png

Ferison

export?options%5Bembed%5D=true&options%5Bformat%5D=.png